• how do we quantify risk

  • They map their own framework back to other frameworks

  • They wanted a comprehensive taxonomy to map. People hate doing all these one off assessments for the regulators

  • Too much time on compliance and not enough on defense

  • NIST CSF 2.0 resonates but missed some pieces from FFIEC

  • CRI profile is a meta framework

  • How did Sallie Mae adopt it

    • They used to have to CAT tool
    • They used Tandem with the CAT tool
    • Moved to 2.0 this year
    • They used the affiliated tool Axio
    • Straightforward to walk through questions and automatically maps to the other frameworks
    • Second line does a credible challenge of answers
    • GRC aligned policies with CRI
  • Evidenced controls and with a maturity view through CRI - CRI helped them build a control framework

  • How hard is it to gather evidence or examples?

    • Depends on how you deal with evidence and what your IA or regulator like to see
  • Challenges to adopting, control mapping - implementation

    • It’s a spreadsheet, but it’s big
    • They are developing a slimmed down version for soon
    • They developed partnerships with innovators to move off of spreadsheets - service now, palo alto networks, axios for SaaS versions
    • These are point in time - how to be continuous
    • From 1st line and 2nd line - first then second
      • Can you show examples of effective evidence?
      • These are just examples
    • 2.0 integrated IT and operations and infrastructure handbook from FFIEC and IT flavored items
  • Challenges in implementation

    • Just had to build it and check policies
    • Took two meetings a week for a whole year
    • Just a bunch of from scratch work
    • Cross referencing policies to controls is where the work is
  • Replaces the CAT assessment

  • 2.0 looks in project management and change management as well

  • We need to embrace the new stuff and get relationships with other teams - partner with 2nd line

  • There is tiering for different levels

    • There’s angst around asset size
    • Asset size is not the best determinant for cyber
    • It’s about impact to economy
    • Lower tiers are usually community impact
    • Tier 4 is to customers and contractual 3rd parties
  • How to present CRI to the board

    • Number of findings and where we are
    • Start doing year over year with a separate update for the board with more details and in a way that aligns with the exercises
    • Preread like Amazon
  • Lots of firm interrogating control effectiveness

  • NCUA has taken a lone wolf approach - NCUA may take what’s left of the CAT and update it

  • Talk to them to become an innovator

  • Inherent risk in CRI -be careful with inherent risk - it’s like an apple product where you can’t get in a break it apart

  • Who to contact for innovator stuff?

  • Q&A

    • I hate doing things in big spreadsheets
    • We hate ticking and tying
    • Integrating this with documentation or wikis?
      • Partial vs complete
    • How to map out day to day work for technical teams to these?
    • How easy is it to develop over the CRI framework such as the innovators have done? What’s the licensing?
  • Todos

    • Tool to find stuff in obsidian and map back to framework using AI?